Welcome to GODFATHERS PIZZA - CAYUGA
GODFATHERS PIZZA - CAYUGA is a cherished local gem located at 20 Talbot St W, Cayuga, ON. Known for its warm, inviting atmosphere and friendly service, this pizza haven offers a delightful array of options, including classic favorites and specialty creations like the "Deluxe Slice" and "Aloha." With a reputation built on quality and nostalgia, patrons rave about the freshly made pizzas and the accommodating staff. Highlights include their vegetarian selections, salads, and mouthwatering wings, all promising satisfaction at every bite. Whether you're a lifelong fan or a first-time visitor, this pizzeria aims to leave a lasting impression.
-
20 Talbot St W, Cayuga, ON N0A 1E0, Canada20 Talbot St W, Cayuga, ON N0A 1E0, Canada Hotline: +1 905-772-9000
Welcome to Godfather's Pizza - Cayuga, a beloved cornerstone of the Cayuga community, nestled at 20 Talbot St W, Cayuga, ON N0A 1E0, Canada. This pizza haven has become synonymous with quality, warmth, and delectable flavors that transport you back to the comforting embrace of home-cooked meals.
At Godfather's, every slice tells a story. The aroma of freshly baked pizza fills the air, inviting you to indulge in a culinary journey. Here, you can enjoy a range of pizza styles, from the classic Deluxe Slice to specialty options like the Kelly's Kraving, each crafted with the freshest ingredients. With a notable Just Cheese Big Slice & Pop for just CA$5.95, it’s an ideal choice for lunch on-the-go. There’s also the Deluxe Slice & Pop for a mere CA$6.70 that doesn't skimp on flavor.
The menu goes beyond just pizza. For those looking to indulge their taste buds further, the Caesar Salad, priced at CA$7.99, offers a crisp and refreshing contrast to the rich cheese and savory toppings. Don’t forget to try the Garlic Strips for CA$9.49 or the flavorful Wings at CA$14.99, perfect for sharing or satisfying a simple craving.
What truly sets Godfather's Pizza - Cayuga apart is its commitment to exceptional service. Customers have shared unforgettable experiences that go beyond just enjoying great food. Jack Johnson recalls a kind gesture where he received a free slice, showcasing the warm-hearted service that feels like family. Repeat visitors like David Kopyl often reflect on cherished memories of enjoying pizza during family outings, highlighting how Godfather’s has become a staple in their lives over time.
The atmosphere emanates nostalgia, with staff members who are both friendly and attentive. Reviewers have praised the team for consistently delivering fresh, delicious pizzas, as noted by Katherine Hedley after her visit when she enjoyed perfect toppings and a fantastic taste. Laura Beth Steiner echoed similar sentiments, expressing gratitude for the enthusiastic staff who make each visit memorable.
In Cayuga, Godfather's Pizza is not just a dining choice; it’s an experience filled with flavors, smiles, and cherished local community connections. Whether you’re a lifetime resident or just passing through, make sure to stop by and discover the pizza that many have loved for years.
For orders or inquiries, give them a call at +1 905-772-9000. Your perfect slice awaits!
Went there for lunch and there was only one slice of pizza left and she kindly gave it to me for free! There was also a guy there that wasn’t able to pay and let him have it, very nice service!
Passing thru this town we always have to stop here. We order and get what we've asked . Pleasant service . Happy and helpful lady. Also brings back some memories of when I was young and my grandfather would stop in here for me while he visited the local hardware store.
Biased opinion because I've gone to this one since I was a kid. But best pizza ever, if you're in Cayuga definitely get lunch here
I ordered a pizza on Tuesday, December 5, 2023 and it was a great pizza! Kudos to the girls working that night because the pizza was absolutely delicious - and the toppings were perfect!
Always great staff who are friendly and helpful and pizza is always fresh - thank you!
Nice people working and such great food! 100% worth it
Called ahead for pickup. Very polite lady helped me decide what to order. I bought x3 pizzas, x3lbs of wings and x2 garlic&cheese bread strips. Cost approx 95 but well worth it. Delicious food, decent prices based on this. I am happy and will return.
I was visiting in Cayuga with some family and ordered pizza for our reunion. Megan was the person serving us and she was exceptional. She was so patient and kind while we ordered and was quick to serve us. We had a lovely experience thanks to her!